Why am I being asked my caste?
By a Confused Indian | 2010-07-19 11:04:25
Three weeks ago the census workers knocked on my door. After asking me
about my educational qualification, profession et al, they popped the
question, "What is your caste?"
I was taken by surprise since, as per the news reports, the issue of
whether to include caste in census is still being debated. But
obviously, like many things in India, our rulers have no clue what is
happening outside the limits of Lutyen's Delhi.
My answer to that loaded question was "my caste is Indian." The
enumerator did give me a quizzical look, but did not comment. She made
her notes and went away. I do not know what she is going to report
I was then reminded of the stern warning given by our honourable Law
Minister that it was my duty to co-operate in census operations and
failure to do so would invite the charge of obstructing a government
servant from doing his duty.
But, Mr Law Minister, I have some genuine doubts and I hope you will
clear them since you have been very vocal about including caste in
My place in the caste system
The origin of caste is the Chatur Varna, or fourfold division. The
Bhagavad Gita, chapter IV, stanza 13 says that God divided humankind
into a fourfold division - the Brahman or the intellectual, teacher
and administrator, Kshatriya or the defender and ruler, Vaishya or the
trader, artisan and farmer, and Shudra, the menial worker.
The stanza clearly says that this division is based on Guna and Karma
(qualities or ability and deeds or application). There is no mention
Incidentally, before the ignorant start screaming Brahminical
conspiracy, the Bhagavad Gita was told by an OBC to a Kshatriya and
was written by an SC/ST (with a thousand apologies to Purushottam Lord
Krishna, who was a Yadav, Arjun, who was a Kshatriya, and
Sage/Maharishi Ved Vyas, who was from a scheduled caste).
I am aware that our esteemed cultural minister would say all this is
fiction and myth, but nevertheless, I will stick to my guns.
I was born in a Brahmin family; my father was a minor civil servant,
so I suppose he qualified as a Brahmin.
But then, I broke the family tradition and joined the armed forces;
that should, in all fairness, make me a Kshatriya.
But post retirement, about 20 years ago, I took up teaching and
research. That should make me a Brahmin again.
The new caste - Rajnitigya
However, while this may be fine in theory, in practice, the caste or
varna system over the years has certainly degenerated into becoming
birth-based. Why just the varna system, in the last 60 years we have
seen birth of a new caste, that of 'Rajnitigya' (Politician).
It would be an interesting exercise under the RTI (Right to
Information) Act to find out how many of our rulers (MPs, MLA's and
sundry elected representatives) are brothers, sisters, sons or
daughters or sons-in-law, wives or daughters-in-law of the rulers.
Mr Law Minister, since you represent the biggest feudal party of
India, I would be obliged if you could provide me this information.
I have a sneaking suspicion that the enthusiasm for a birth-based
caste is, like the good old Brahmins, a clever attempt by the
Rajnitigya caste to perpetuate their monopoly over power.
Who is backward in today's India?
Coming back to the distortion of the caste system, it was most cruel
to the shudras, who suffered all kind of indignities and did not have
a chance to move upwards till the modern era and pioneering work of
Hindu social reformers, saints and leadership of Dr. Ambedkar.
That is why there is a national consensus on quotas for the scheduled
castes and, to some extent, scheduled tribes as well.
But in case of the OBC, the issues are very different. It is common
throughout Indian history for the farmers to have become
This has been observed in the Jats in Haryana and Punjab, Marathas in
Maharashtra and various farming communities in the South. These
communities are also the biggest landholders, dominate politics and
are in virtually all professions.
Even in the case of other professions, like potters, barbers etc, how
many are still carrying on their ancestral profession?
Let us look at some concrete examples.
One of the largest princely states in Madhya Pradesh was ruled by a
family that came from the caste of shepherds. Are they to record
their caste as shepherds and enjoy concessions?
Yadavs from UP and Bihar, at the forefront of caste-concession
movement, may consider themselves backward, but in Maharashtra, they
were the last major rulers at Daulatabad (Devagiri near Aurangabad).
And what of the several Generals and Colonels? Are they of backward
castes and a soldier of a forward caste?
In my avatar as Kshatriya, I vividly remember an incident. I joined an
infantry battalion in 1968. The battalion was posted in Ladakh at that
One day, the battalion barber, while giving me a haircut, asked me if
I knew an officer called Trivikram Singh. It so happened that he was
one term my senior in Zozila Company (of the Indian Military Academy,
So I said yes, of course I knew him, and that he was my senior. With
obvious pride, the battalion barber told me that Trivikram was his
As an officer of the Indian Army, Mr Moily, what caste should
Trivikram fall into? Barber?
Incidentally, some of the battalions including the one that I joined
were entirely composed of the so-called forward castes. All our
soldiers are Kshatriyas and Thakurs. It is also mandatory that all our
cooks are Brahmins, for traditionally, the upper caste will only eat
food cooked by a Brahmin.
But a lot of water has flowed down the Ganga since then, and in the
1980s, out of the ten-twelve officers of the battalion, no less than
half were Yadavs, a supposed backward caste.
So we had a paradoxical situation. While the educationally, socially
and economically backward jawans were supposedly 'forward', their
officers were 'backward', and their children were to get special
treatment and concessions.
If this is not travesty of justice, then what is?
What about mixed marriages? Does the caste of girl/boy change after
marriage? Before the casteist bloggers howl blue murder, let me
clarify that in my closest family we have had several such inter-caste
marriages. So Mr Moily, it is not just an academic question for many
Caste and class
Caste does not equal Class.
Late Ram Manohar Lohia, possibly the most destructive personality of
independent India, propagated a concept that equated caste with class.
Class in this sense is both economic and social classification. Thus
it was a short leap for the casteist leaders to justify their approach
and then take shelter under the constitution that mandates 'special
measures' to help backward classes.
Let us look at this skulduggery in the light of Indian reality.
The King who was Kshatriya, was at the top of social hierarchy. The
soldier who guarded his palace was also a Kshatriya and of the same
caste. But do they belong to same class?
A Brahmin was the minister and advisor to King. Another Brahmin cooked
his meals, while yet another was the priest of the royal temple. Can
they be of same class?
The Nagar Seth, or the chief merchant, often a member of the royal
court, was lower in the so-called caste hierarchy than both the
Brahmin and Kshatriya. But were the soldier guards of the palace or
the royal cook, of a higher class than he?
The truth is that even in the most regressive period of the Indian
caste system, class and caste were not synonymous. In the modern era,
it is even more so.
But equating them for reservation at the national level has played
havoc with the country. For instance, in Maharashtra, thanks to Dr.
Ambedkar and efforts of the community, the Mahars have virtually
monopolised the SC reservations. We now have families of IAS/IPS
monopolising the concessions. This has left the real deserving out of
Even more glaring is in inequity of Tribal reservations. Virtually the
entire quota is usurped by the tribals from North East. Can anyone
show me a single Gond, Katkari, Madia or Warli tribal in the elite
The growth of Naxalism in Central India is the direct result of this
terrible distortion. Sadly, there is no exit clause from this. So we
have even a daughter of a former President, former Speaker or such
worthy, eligible for concessions.
Caste in census – and what next?
Let us not kid ourselves - the whole rationale behind asking for caste
in census is to then ask for more reservations on the basis of
percentage in population.
Are we to then become a country that follows proportional
representation in all walks of life?
Let us also look at a hypothetical case of a caste that calls itself
backward. What is going to be the criterion for its educational and
social backwardness? Will a caste be declared forward if, say, 51% of
its members become graduates? Or will we await a day when 100% are
How do we measure social backwardness? Can social backwardness be
cured by reservation in jobs or with social reforms? Can the
government legislate social reforms?
It is another Shah Bano moment for the Congress party (when the party
bowed to obscurantist elements and denied alimony to a Muslim
A misstep at this stage will be a trigger for another bout of
Mandal-like divisiveness and would mean handing over the country to
Khaps (caste panchayats) and take the country backwards.
Perhaps we should declare everyone backward so that there is no
conflict, and then begin a race to the starting line, running
Historically, India was at the top during the agricultural epoch of
the history of mankind. The whole focus was thus towards the
perfection of existing technology and skills.
There was thus no incentive to be inventive and all benefits and
profits were seen in refinement of existing skills. It can be seen in
many walks of life that Indians continue to use instruments and
techniques practised for thousands of years. In no small measure, this
gave rise to birth based 'caste' system where a son followed the
profession of his father. It was practical.
There were several exceptions, where people changed their professions,
but the norm was to follow tradition.
Dr. Ambedkar was one of the severest critics of Gandhi on this ground,
as Gandhi extolled the virtues of village life while Ambedkar rightly
saw that as a disaster.
The result of this feudal approach was that war was seen to be an
activity exclusive to the warrior caste, with the rest of the society
Despite its huge population, in all its major wars, the Indian armies
were generally numerically inferior to the invaders. Not only was the
caste system the cause of India's loss of independence, it was largely
responsible for the country's other misfortunes.
Through the caste survey, caste leaders want to turn the wheel back to
bad old days, shun social reform and jeopardise the dream of
Urbanisation and industrialisation are the forces that break caste barriers.
Soon more than 50 per cent of our population will be living in urban
areas. To revert to rural caste identities at this stage is a
The main motivation behind this resurrection of caste is the fear of
becoming politically irrelevant.
So should we say to hell with the future peace and security of our nation?
Should we further divide the country on caste lines, and have a repeat
of the violent Gujjar agitation in Rajasthan, with people fighting to
be declared backward?
The saddest part is that even the so-called young leaders of this
community, who should know better, do not dare to swim against the
These are not leaders, but followers, of their followers.
Get all ZESTCaste mails sent out in a span of 24 hours in a single mail. Subscribe to the daily digest version by sending a blank mail to ZESTMediafirstname.lastname@example.org, OR, if you have a Yahoo! Id, change your settings at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTMedia/join/
On this list you can share caste news, discuss caste issues and network with like-minded anti-caste people from across India and the world. Just write to email@example.com
TELL FRIENDS TO SIGN UP:-
If you got this mail as a forward, subscribe to ZESTCaste by sending a blank mail to ZESTCastefirstname.lastname@example.org OR, if you have a Yahoo! ID, by visiting http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTCaste/join/
Also have a look at our sister list, ZESTMedia: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTMedia/Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
<*> Your email settings:
Individual Email | Traditional
<*> To change settings online go to:
(Yahoo! ID required)
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: